In second place, I have Gabriel Jesus.
It might be surprising to some that I have him second, considering I am a big supporter of expected goals. And the metric says over his premier league career, Jesus has underperformed what is expected of an average striker by 18 goals. Simply put, the data suggests Gabriel Jesus is a well below-average finisher.
So, why do I have him in second? Context. That context is that despite playing in six premier league seasons for Manchester City, Gabriel Jesus only started five or more league games in a row eight times. So out of 228 possible games, Jesus has only been allowed the rhythm of consistent starts a few times. And anyone who has played the sport at a competitive level can tell you the difference regular playing time can have in confidence and performance. And if you're thinking, well, maybe if he played better, he would have started more games, that would be wrong. Across those eight occasions totaling 46 games, Jesus contributed an efficient 24 goals and 12 assists. Even more impressive when you consider a significant chunk of those games came from a wide position and not as the focal point of the attack.
At Arsenal, Jesus will receive consistent starts for the first time in his career, and he'll be the focal point of one of the most dangerous attacks in the league. We saw a glimpse of this opportunity in a preseason campaign that saw him score seven goals in five games.